SIGIPSELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INCvs its industry peers
A metric-by-metric comparison of SELECTIVE INSURANCE GROUP INC against SIC 6331 — valuation, growth, profitability, quality and total return, with each figure's rank within the peer group. Every value is Go-computed from SEC filings and delayed prices; ranks are sorted positions within the group only — descriptive, not advice.
| Company | Market cap | P/E (TTM) | P/B | P/S | Revenue growth (YoY) | Earnings growth (YoY) | EBIT margin | ROE | ROIC | Piotroski F | 1y total return | Dividend yield |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| SIGIPThis | $881M#8 | 1.8x#3 | 0.3x#1 | 0.2x#2 | 9.8%#7 | 125.3%#5 | 11.0%#12 | 13.5%#9 | 11.4%#8 | — | -6.5%#12 | 10.5%#3 |
| KMPB | $1.5B#1 | — | 0.7x#3 | 0.3x#3 | 3.3%#11 | -54.9%#14 | -1.4%#14 | 6.5%#13 | -1.9%#11 | — | 10.6%#9 | 5.4%#4 |
| UVE | $1.4B#2 | 6.1x#6 | 2.1x#13 | 0.8x#5 | 5.5%#8 | 210.5%#3 | 15.6%#7 | 28.3%#4 | 108.0%#3 | — | 61.1%#1 | 1.6%#7 |
| AFGE | $1.3B#3 | 1.3x#1 | 0.3x#2 | 0.2x#1 | -1.8%#13 | -5.1%#11 | 13.1%#9 | 17.5%#7 | 15.0%#6 | — | 25.4%#6 | 48.4%#1 |
| ASIC | $1.2B#4 | 11.2x#11 | 1.8x#11 | 2.7x#15 | 23.4%#5 | 57.2%#8 | 22.4%#5 | 11.1%#11 | — | — | 25.0%#7 | — |
| BOW | $1.1B#5 | 18.5x#12 | 2.4x#16 | 2.0x#13 | 29.6%#3 | 40.6%#10 | 12.2%#10 | 11.4%#10 | 11.3%#9 | — | 40.7%#3 | — |
| HRTG | $1.1B#6 | 5.1x#4 | 1.9x#12 | 1.3x#9 | 3.7%#10 | 217.8%#2 | 31.5%#3 | 34.5%#1 | 392.0%#1 | — | 54.8%#2 | 0.0%#10 |
| HIPO | $935M#7 | 28.5x#14 | 2.1x#14 | 2.0x#12 | 25.9%#4 | 318.9%#1 | 13.5%#8 | 14.4%#8 | — | — | -3.7%#11 | — |
| EIG | $815M#9 | 26.3x#13 | 1.0x#6 | 0.9x#6 | -2.5%#14 | -90.9%#16 | 2.1%#13 | 1.4%#15 | 1.9%#10 | — | — | 3.7%#5 |
| TIPT | $642M#10 | 1.6x#2 | 0.7x#4 | 1314.8x#16 | -67.9%#16 | -34.6%#13 | -9574.6%#16 | 3.9%#14 | — | — | 0.8%#10 | 1.4%#8 |
| AII | $581M#11 | 7.0x#7 | 1.6x#9 | 2.1x#14 | 35.3%#2 | 150.7%#4 | 41.6%#2 | 27.0%#5 | 122.0%#2 | — | 25.0%#8 | — |
| ACIC | $528M#12 | 5.4x#5 | 1.6x#8 | 1.6x#11 | 13.1%#6 | 41.1%#9 | 41.8%#1 | 31.3%#3 | 38.6%#4 | — | — | — |
| GLRE | $517M#13 | 9.4x#9 | 0.7x#5 | 0.7x#4 | 4.8%#9 | 74.8%#7 | 11.6%#11 | 10.8%#12 | 12.9%#7 | — | 31.6%#5 | — |
| AMSF | $378M#14 | 9.5x#10 | 1.6x#10 | 1.2x#8 | 2.7%#12 | -15.0%#12 | 18.7%#6 | 19.9%#6 | — | — | -42.2%#13 | 12.9%#2 |
| NODK | $303M#15 | 39.1x#15 | 1.2x#7 | 1.1x#7 | -12.3%#15 | -71.8%#15 | -4.3%#15 | -4.2%#16 | -6.2%#12 | — | — | 2.2%#6 |
| KINS | $294M#16 | 8.2x#8 | 2.3x#15 | 1.4x#10 | 38.5%#1 | 122.1%#6 | 25.6%#4 | 31.6%#2 | 34.6%#5 | — | 39.8%#4 | 0.5%#9 |
Peer set: US filers sharing this company's SEC industry classification (SIC 6331). SIC is coarse — conglomerates and multi-segment companies map imperfectly. Values from SEC filings + delayed prices; ranks are within-group positions only. Market cap, P/E, P/B, P/S, 1y total return and dividend yield are computed from each member's latest snapshot price when the table is built (see as-of; snapshot prices can lag) — not live. Some peers are still being computed, so this table covers part of the group and ranks are within the rows shown; it fills in shortly. This table timed out mid-build, so it covers part of the group; ranks are within the rows shown and it fills in shortly. Table built 2026-11-03.
Source: SEC XBRL filings + delayed prices · ranks are within-group positions · For reference only · Not investment advice